MOTHMAN!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MothmanWe've mentioned the Mothman in other threads, and I nearly posted this in the Documentaries thread because it's the recent
Eyes of the Mothman doc which inspired this post.
http://www.netflix.com/Movie/Eyes-of-the-Mothman/70154852At two and a half hours long the doc is slightly long in the tooth. However it's a very thorough, measured, and surprisingly level-headed look at the entire history of the Mothman. The whole thing is really well done, starting off with the true story of Chief Cornstalk (and his curse), then explaining the history and environmental issues surrounding the TNT plant where many of the Mothman sightings are centered, and even offering alternative explanations besides cryptids and aliens.
The section on Woody Derenberger (late of Parkersburg, WV) and his meeting with the mysterious "man in black" Indrid Cold is a sphincter clinching horror movie sequence that alone is worth giving the doc a try.
RC says check it out.