I am disturbed to report that... I liked Dial of Destiny.
RC, who has become cynical in his old age, said that was just because Crystal Skull was so awful I would have been happy if a Labrador pissed in my mouth. But, no, Dial actually did something. It was a cohesive, interesting, fun story. Geriatric Jones was more just there as a foil for Phoebe Bridge who knocked it out of the park (and was also clearly auditioning to be the next Doctor Who and/or James Bond).
Mads Mikkelsen brought his usual low-key power to his role. In fact, I'd say that he made the movie. Without Mads it would have been shit.
They lost their balls at the end though. They had this perfect moment where Indy should have died. In fact, there is no other way Indy could ever die except in that perfect moment. He should have put the fedora on Phoebe's head and bowed out gracefully in this one perfect Indy's going to die moment.
But...nope. Fucking cowards in the writers room. Indy remains alive and well, and they even dug up Karen Allen for him.
Young Indy was great. The only uncanny valley aspect of it was 80 year old Ford voicing 35 year old Indy. So it looks great, then he talks and it's the reedy, crackly old man voice.
Much better done, and much more subtle, was CGI young Mads. The junior Nazi scientist in 1939. You didn't even realize you were dealing with the uncanny valley with him because Mads is eternal!
Totally agree with the (strangely, surprisingly, refreshingly) steady hand on the nostalgia porn. The only nods I noticed was one dialogue reference to Temple, and a visual ref to the same, Last Crusade, and Raiders. But all done as general background. The most obvious was Temple (the hallway of bugs, coming right after a discussion about drinking the blood of Kali). The tomb was Crusade, but it didn't matter. There was a nod to Raiders, but in a natural, normal, thought-out way. Really strange that they were able to hold their hand there. Because, Jesus. Disney CANNOT stop themselves from pouring on the nostalgia porn. So whoever won that battle deserves a medal because it saved the movie.
Now....what they need to do is what they wanted to do with River Phoenix back in the day: Phoebe takes over and becomes the new Jones. Adventures continue with her throughout the 70s and 80s. Perfect! Listen to me, fuckers! No....they won't.